As Ghanaians struggle with the daily challenges of managing their finances, one recurring concern looms large: the price of petroleum products. From fueling vehicles to powering homes, the fluctuations in oil prices directly impact the livelihoods of every citizen.
Recently, the National Petroleum Authority (NPA) unveiled an amended pricing guideline, introducing the concept of price floors for petroleum products.
According to the Amendment to the Pricing Guidelines, the NPA “shall set and communicate price floors for the deregulated products for each pricing window.”
This move, ostensibly aimed at price stabilization, has ignited a debate, prompting questions regarding the NPA’s alignment with the interests of the average Ghanaian.
A floor price is the minimum price that can be legally charged for a product or service. It protects consumers by ensuring that prices do not drop below a certain level, which can help maintain quality standards, prevent predatory pricing practices, and ensure fair compensation for producers or service providers.
On the other hand, price ceilings represent the maximum price allowable, safeguarding consumers against exorbitant costs. Both mechanisms serve as regulatory tools, but their relevance hinges on prevailing market dynamics.
In a new press release, NPA explained that the price floor will not affect competition between OMCs and others in the energy sector nor will it impose high prices on consumers as the Africa Centre for Energy Policy ACEP and other stakeholders fear.
“NPA is mandated by its Act to protect the interest of consumers and Petroleum Service Providers (PSPs) alike and uses its policies and regulations to achieve this mandate. A multi-stakeholder committee was established in 2021 with representation from all key stakeholders in the industry to assess the price deregulation policy which has been in operation since July 2015.”
“One of the major concerns that emerged from the committee’s work was the inability of PSPs to sometimes fully recover their costs due to unhealthy price competition that sometimes occurs amongst them. The proposed solution to the above concerns is to set “price floors for BIDECs and OMCS/LPGMCS which take into consideration only the fixed costs, taxes, levies, statutory and distribution margins in the Prescribed Petroleum Pricing Formula. These are costs that apply to all PSPs.”
NPA’s press release
NPA’s Price Floors Threatening Competition and Consumer Choice
Presently, Ghana’s petroleum sector boasts a competitive landscape, with various Oil Marketing Companies (OMCs) vying for market share. These OMCs, ranging from industry giants to smaller enterprises, adopt diverse pricing strategies.
While larger corporations often apply higher profit margins, smaller players tend to operate on narrower margins. However, despite this divergence, smaller OMCs remain profitable and operational, offering consumers a range of choices based on their preferences and budget constraints.
By stipulating a minimum price threshold, the NPA effectively imposes a uniform standard across all OMCs. Moreover, the purported issue of price instability appears unsubstantiated, as smaller OMCs have demonstrated resilience within the existing competitive framework.
In light of prevailing economic forecasts projecting an upward trajectory in oil prices, a different approach seems warranted. Rather than enforcing price floors, a more prudent strategy would entail the imposition of price ceilings.
By capping prices at a reasonable level, the NPA could shield consumers from abrupt price surges while ensuring the continued viability of OMCs. This balanced approach strikes a chord between consumer protection and industry sustainability.
The emphasis on price floors raises suspicions regarding the NPA’s motives. Such measures could disproportionately benefit larger OMCs at the expense of smaller competitors and, ultimately, the average Ghanaian consumer. Furthermore, standardizing prices could erode the competitive advantage of smaller players, thereby reducing pricing diversity and limiting consumer choice.
In a market-driven economy, competition serves as the bedrock of innovation and efficiency. It fosters a dynamic environment where businesses strive to meet consumer demands at competitive prices. By mandating price floors, the NPA risks stifling this competitive spirit, thereby impeding progress and inhibiting market growth.
READ ALSO: Medikal’s UK Show Overshadowed
