• About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
Wednesday, July 23, 2025
  • Login
The Vaultz News
  • Top Stories
  • News
    • General News
    • Education
    • Health
    • Opinions
  • Economics
    • Economy
    • Finance
      • Banking
      • Insurance
      • Pension
    • Securities/Markets
  • Business
    • Agribusiness
    • Vaultz Business
    • Extractives/Energy
    • Real Estate
  • World
    • Africa
    • America
    • Europe
    • UK
    • USA
    • Asia
    • Around the Globe
  • Innovation
    • Technology
    • Wheels
  • Entertainment
  • 20MOBPL2DNew
  • Jobs & Scholarships
    • Job Vacancies
    • Scholarships
No Result
View All Result
The Vaultz News
  • Top Stories
  • News
    • General News
    • Education
    • Health
    • Opinions
  • Economics
    • Economy
    • Finance
      • Banking
      • Insurance
      • Pension
    • Securities/Markets
  • Business
    • Agribusiness
    • Vaultz Business
    • Extractives/Energy
    • Real Estate
  • World
    • Africa
    • America
    • Europe
    • UK
    • USA
    • Asia
    • Around the Globe
  • Innovation
    • Technology
    • Wheels
  • Entertainment
  • 20MOBPL2DNew
  • Jobs & Scholarships
    • Job Vacancies
    • Scholarships
No Result
View All Result
The Vaultz News
No Result
View All Result

Due Process Dead Amid CJ Petition Shortcuts

April 16, 2025
Lilian Ahedorby Lilian Ahedor
in General News
0
Suspended Chief Justice's case at the ECOWAS Court raises concern

Justice Gertrude Torkornoo, Suspended Chief Justice - Ghana.

In Ghana’s ever-evolving democratic journey, one thing remains clear: due process is non-negotiable. At the heart of this process lies audi alteram partem—“hear the other side.” 

Accordingly, legal scholar and Democracy and Development Fellow at CDD-Ghana, Prof. Stephen Kwaku Asare, has taken a bold stance on the integrity of judicial independence in the absence of due process. 

He challenged how Ghana’s constitutional mechanisms handle petitions—especially those seeking the removal of high-ranking judicial officials like the Chief Justice.

RelatedPosts

Mahama Refers Electoral Violence Report to Attorney-General for Legal Review

GHC 138bn Massive Public Debt Error Raises Accountability Fears

Agorhom Accepts Blame for NPP’s 2024 Accra Losses

In a detailed and impassioned statement, Prof. Asare argued that the Constitution’s Article 146(6) clearly defines a two-step procedure for the removal of the Chief Justice: the filter phase and the forum phase. 

“The filter stage, then the petitioner must, under the same principle of natural justice, be entitled to see and respond to that reply. Audi alteram partem is not satisfied by hearing just one side behind closed doors. I still maintain that the Constitution does not require the President to hear from the Chief Justice at the prima facie stage at all.”

Prof. Stephen Kwaku Asare

Prof. Asare emphasized that the filter phase is supposed to be a gatekeeping stage, led by the President in consultation with the Council of State, to determine if a petition raises a prima facie case. 

According to him, the forum phase, on the other hand, is where a full investigation occurs, with both sides given the chance to argue, rebut, and present evidence.

However, in the wake of his own petition to remove the Chief Justice, Prof. Asare revealed that something went awry at the filter phase. 

The former President, H.E. Akufo-Addo, he alleged, sought a response from the Chief Justice before determining whether a prima facie case existed, without informing him, the petitioner, of this development.

Prof. Asare weighs in on the need to enforce due process
Professor Stephen Kwaku Azar Asare

“I recently submitted a petition for the removal of the Chief Justice. Consistent with the Constitution’s design, I expected the [former] President and the Council of State to assess the petition based on its contents—nothing more.” 

Prof. Stephen Kwaku Asare

That expectation was dashed when he discovered that a response from the Chief Justice had been solicited and factored into the President’s decision, yet the response was not disclosed to him. 

This step taken by former President Akufo-Addo, according to Prof. Asare, is a betrayal of procedural fairness.

“At the very least, I should have been given a copy of that response. I should have had the benefit of reading it, understanding it, and, if necessary, responding to it. That is the bare minimum the rules of natural justice require.”

Prof. Stephen Kwaku Asare

Due Process Fails, Legitimacy Drowns 

Due process is not just a procedural formality—it is the foundation of any healthy democracy, and Prof. Asare’s position underscores this principle. 

due process in CJ removal petition; judicial independence in focus
Law

He argued that when a petitioner is denied the opportunity to respond to a rebuttal that ultimately shapes the decision on their petition, the entire legitimacy of the process is compromised. “Without that opportunity, I was denied a voice in a conversation that decided the fate of my petition.”

The failure to share the Chief Justice’s rebuttal meant he was left powerless to point out flaws, inconsistencies, or contradictions in a document that weighed heavily on the final decision.

Prof. Asare made it clear that his call for due process to be followed is not a plea to reverse a personal outcome. Instead, it is a call for reform—one rooted in the democratic values that underpin the Constitution. 

He emphasized that this issue must be confronted now, before more petitioners find themselves voiceless in the face of power.

“I raise it to prompt a serious reconsideration of how we structure and execute the Article 146 process going forward. Because if the Constitution is to be a living instrument, then its application must evolve to reflect not just formal legality, but fairness, balance, and transparency.”

Prof. Stephen Kwaku Asare

In no uncertain terms, Prof. Asare warned that any process permitting secret rebuttals or one-sided assessments risks becoming a tool that shields the powerful and silences the citizenry.

the rule of law in Ghana
Martyrs of the Rule of Law Marker

“If the President chooses to receive and rely on the judge’s response at the filter stage, then the petitioner must, under the same principle of natural justice, be entitled to see and respond to that reply. Audi alteram partem is not satisfied by hearing just one side behind closed doors.”

Prof. Stephen Kwaku Asare

As such, Prof. Asare maintained that even with proposed modifications, the current approach remains flawed. 

He believes the best course is to strictly uphold the original intent of Article 146(6), which envisions the filter stage as a simple threshold check, without inviting or considering responses from the subject of the petition.

He believes the President and the Council of State must assess petitions strictly on their merit and content, in line with the principles of due process.

The appropriate space for rebuttals and equal engagement is during the forum phase, where both parties can present their case.

Accordingly, he emphasized that turning the initial filter into a quasi-trial undermines the constitutional design and compromises fairness.

He argued that when due process is subject to individual discretion rather than a rule-based procedure, justice becomes selective. 

This, he warned, risks corroding not only public faith in the judiciary but also in the broader democratic framework.

Prof. Asare’s concluding reflections are both cautionary and aspirational. He urged Ghana not to wait for further petitions or procedural missteps before reforming the process.

According to him, this reform must serve the Constitution, treat all parties fairly, and truly uphold the ideals of justice.

Because, as he rightly states, “Justice must not only be done. It must be done fairly, openly, and for all sides.”

READ ALSO: Trump Orders Tariff Probe to Curb China’s Mineral Grip 

Tags: Constitutional LawDue processGhana Judiciarylegal reformStephen Kwaku Asare
Please login to join discussion
Previous Post

Stonebwoy To Raise Funds for Pediatric Clinics

Next Post

Launched; One Million Coders to Transform Ghana And Africa’s Economy

[mc4wp_form id="1264"]

Related Posts

President John Dramani Mahama and Attorney General Dr Dominic Ayine
General News

Mahama Refers Electoral Violence Report to Attorney-General for Legal Review

July 23, 2025
Davido Pays Tribute To Late Son Ifeanyi
Entertainment

Davido Pays Tribute To Late Son Ifeanyi

July 23, 2025
Stanbic Ghana Shines as Standard Bank Group Sweeps Euromoney Honors
Banking

Stanbic Ghana Shines as Standard Bank Group Sweeps Euromoney Honors

July 23, 2025
PAC Chair decries public debt mismatch
General News

GHC 138bn Massive Public Debt Error Raises Accountability Fears

July 23, 2025
Richie Mensah Reveals Kuami Eugene’s Status With Record Label
Entertainment

Artists Deserve Freedom Beyond Record Labels

July 23, 2025
Sudan’s Civilian Bloc Backs ‘Diplomatic War’ Push
Africa

Sudan’s Civilian Bloc Backs ‘Diplomatic War’ Push

July 23, 2025
President John Dramani Mahama and Attorney General Dr Dominic Ayine
General News

Mahama Refers Electoral Violence Report to Attorney-General for Legal Review

by Evans Junior OwuJuly 23, 2025
Davido Pays Tribute To Late Son Ifeanyi
Entertainment

Davido Pays Tribute To Late Son Ifeanyi

by Esther Korantemaa OffeiJuly 23, 2025
Stanbic Ghana Shines as Standard Bank Group Sweeps Euromoney Honors
Banking

Stanbic Ghana Shines as Standard Bank Group Sweeps Euromoney Honors

by Stephen M.CJuly 23, 2025
PAC Chair decries public debt mismatch
General News

GHC 138bn Massive Public Debt Error Raises Accountability Fears

by Lilian AhedorJuly 23, 2025
Richie Mensah Reveals Kuami Eugene’s Status With Record Label
Entertainment

Artists Deserve Freedom Beyond Record Labels

by Esther Korantemaa OffeiJuly 23, 2025
Sudan’s Civilian Bloc Backs ‘Diplomatic War’ Push
Africa

Sudan’s Civilian Bloc Backs ‘Diplomatic War’ Push

by Lawrence AnkutseJuly 23, 2025
President John Dramani Mahama and Attorney General Dr Dominic Ayine
Davido Pays Tribute To Late Son Ifeanyi
Stanbic Ghana Shines as Standard Bank Group Sweeps Euromoney Honors
PAC Chair decries public debt mismatch
Richie Mensah Reveals Kuami Eugene’s Status With Record Label
Sudan’s Civilian Bloc Backs ‘Diplomatic War’ Push
[/vc_row_inner]

Recent News

  • Mahama Refers Electoral Violence Report to Attorney-General for Legal Review
  • Davido Pays Tribute To Late Son Ifeanyi
  • Stanbic Ghana Shines as Standard Bank Group Sweeps Euromoney Honors
  • GHC 138bn Massive Public Debt Error Raises Accountability Fears
  • Artists Deserve Freedom Beyond Record Labels
The Vaultz News

Copyright © 2021 The Vaultz News. All rights reserved.

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

Follow Us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Top Stories
  • News
    • General News
    • Education
    • Health
    • Opinions
  • Economics
    • Economy
    • Finance
      • Banking
      • Insurance
      • Pension
    • Securities/Markets
  • Business
    • Agribusiness
    • Vaultz Business
    • Extractives/Energy
    • Real Estate
  • World
    • Africa
    • America
    • Europe
    • UK
    • USA
    • Asia
    • Around the Globe
  • Innovation
    • Technology
    • Wheels
  • Entertainment
  • 20MOBPL2D
  • Jobs & Scholarships
    • Job Vacancies
    • Scholarships

Copyright © 2021 The Vaultz News. All rights reserved.