The world of performing arts is rich and varied, with stage plays and films being two of the most prominent forms of storytelling.
While both mediums share the goal of entertaining and engaging audiences, the processes involved in creating a stage play and a film are vastly different, each with unique challenges.
Ghanaian filmmaker, Peter Sedufia has shared his perspective on the challenges of stage acting compared to filmmaking, stating that directing a movie is much easier than performing in stage plays.
The director and producer highlighted his experience in both fields.
According to Sedufia, directing films is enjoyable because it allows him to guide actors in portraying his vision.
He explained that filmmaking gives him the power to shape narratives and influence audiences, making them believe in the stories he presents on screen.
However, he believes stage acting is far more demanding. Having started as a stage actor in primary school and continuing through secondary school, Sedufia noted that performing live requires actors to memorize entire scripts, sometimes spanning 90 pages.
“It is fun to direct because it is something I enjoy doing. It’s about telling people what to do and how to do it, and they follow your direction. It’s about letting the whole world see a certain narrative through your lens. What I tell you is what you believe if I show someone committing a crime in a film, you will believe that the crime happened.
“The power to influence society and shape minds outside the set is what makes directing exciting. Filmmaking is easier for me than stage acting, as I started as a stage actor from primary school through senior secondary school.”
Peter Sedufia
He emphasized that stage actors must have exceptional memory and adaptability since there are no opportunities to correct mistakes once the performance begins. This, he said, makes stage acting much more challenging than filmmaking.
“Memorizing a 90-page script and keeping it all in mind is challenging, especially since there’s no opportunity to pause or ask the director if you got it right.
“Once you start, you have to keep going until the end. Stage actors tend to have excellent memory because they are used to this process. Stage acting is very difficult.”
Peter Sedufia
In theater, the performance is live, meaning that every show is unique. Actors must deliver their lines and portray their characters flawlessly in real time, with no opportunity for retakes.
Any mistakes or unexpected occurrences must be managed on the spot, requiring a high level of skill, adaptability, and composure.
In contrast, filmmaking allows for multiple takes, editing, and post-production enhancements. If an actor fluffs a line or if a scene doesn’t work, filmmakers reshoot or edit the footage to achieve the desired result.
Stage plays typically require extensive rehearsal periods, often spanning several weeks or even months. During this time, actors must memorize their lines, develop their characters, and build chemistry with their co-stars.
The rehearsal process is intensive and demands a high level of commitment and discipline from all involved.
In contrast, film productions sometimes have shorter rehearsal times, as actors only need to familiarize themselves with their lines and the scene before filming begins.
However, the complexity of film schedules, and locations, and the need for coordination among various departments create their own set of challenges.
Audience Interaction of Stage Plays, Filmmaking
Theater is unique in that it offers immediate feedback from the audience. The energy in the room shifts dramatically based on the audience’s reactions, which influences the actors’ performances.
A strong audience response elevates a performance, while a disengaged or unresponsive audience poses challenges for actors trying to maintain their energy and focus.
In filmmaking, the audience does not witness the creation process. The feedback loop is delayed, as viewers only see the final product after it has been edited and released.
While this allows filmmakers to craft a polished narrative, it also means they do not receive real-time feedback that informs their performances or storytelling.
Also, actors in stage plays often have to maintain their character’s emotional arc throughout multiple performances.
This requires a deep understanding of their character and the ability to tap into their emotions consistently, night after night.
The emotional labor involved in delivering a powerful performance live is taxing, leading to burnout or fatigue over time.
In filmmaking, while actors also need to connect with their characters, they have the opportunity to approach scenes with a fresh perspective each day, as filming is done out of sequence.
This provides a different emotional experience, as actors focus on specific moments without the pressure of continuity across live performances.
Community and Collaboration of Stage Play, Filmmaking
Both stage plays and films require collaboration among diverse individuals, including actors, directors, designers, and technicians.
However, the nature of collaboration differs. In theater, the close-knit community often fosters strong relationships, as the same cast and crew work together for an extended period.
This creates a supportive environment but also leads to heightened tensions, especially during intense rehearsals.
Filmmaking involves larger teams and a more hierarchical structure, which sometimes leads to communication challenges.
While filmmakers have the advantage of working with specialists in various fields, the fast-paced nature of film production creates stress and conflict.
Both stage plays and filmmaking present their own unique challenges, and determining which is “tougher” ultimately depends on individual perspectives and experiences.
However, the live nature of theater, the emotional demands placed on actors, and the creative constraints of the medium often make stage plays a formidable endeavor.
The intensity of the live performance, the necessity for immediate adaptability, and the deep emotional investment required from actors contribute to the argument that stage plays are indeed tougher than filmmaking.
READ ALSO: Paapa Darkwah Scrutinizes AG’s Justification of Nolle Prosequi
