Ghana’s recent Treasury bill (T-bill) auction recorded its first undersubscription in six weeks, missing the government’s target of GHS 6.22 billion and securing only GHS 5.17 billion.
This development has sparked concerns about the government’s reliance on short-term debt instruments for financing amid rising yields and mounting domestic debt obligations.
However, Mr. Isaac Kwasi Mensah, a Financial Analyst and Portfolio Manager at SIC Financial Services Limited, in an interview with the Vaultz News, argued that the undersubscription does not necessarily indicate a looming crisis but rather highlights the ongoing market dynamics and fiscal pressures the government faces.
“… While the undersubscription is a deviation from recent trends, it is essential to understand that demand for the government’s short-term debt instruments continues to be strong across all tenors. This shows that investor confidence has not waned significantly, even as the government grapples with a challenging fiscal environment.”
Mr. Isaac Kwasi Mensah
Yield Increases Reflect Market Sentiment
Mr Kwasi Mensah stated that the slight increase in yields recorded across all tenors, is a signal of heightened market demand for higher returns to compensate for perceived risks.
“In the context of a tightening fiscal environment, the yield increases are not surprising. Investors are becoming more cautious as the government’s debt levels rise, prompting a demand for higher interest rates on T-bills to mitigate potential risks associated with Ghana’s growing domestic debt obligations.
“The upward trend in yields may reflect investor sentiment about the current economic environment, characterized by inflationary pressures and uncertainty surrounding fiscal policy. However, it is also a sign of healthy market mechanisms at play, where investors are seeking adequate compensation for the increased risks.”
Mr. Isaac Kwasi Mensah
Under Subscription, not a Sign of a Broader Problem
Despite the undersubscription, the analyst Mr Kwasi Mensah suggested that this single occurrence should not be interpreted as a sign of a broader problem.
He noted that several factors may have contributed to the shortfall, including timing issues and seasonal variations in liquidity. “It is not uncommon for T-bill auctions to experience fluctuations in demand, particularly when market participants anticipate changes in monetary policy or adjustments in interest rates.”
Moreover, Mr Kwasi Mensah averred that the government’s reliance on domestic debt markets to meet its financing needs has been a critical part of its strategy, especially as it faces limited access to international capital markets.
“In this context, the undersubscription can be seen as a temporary setback rather than a fundamental issue with the government’s borrowing strategy. The strong demand across all tenors indicates that there is still confidence in the government’s ability to meet its obligations, even amid rising yields.”
Mr. Isaac Kwasi Mensah
The analyst is of the view that the undersubscription highlights the balance the government must maintain as it navigates its fiscal challenges. On one hand, it needs to raise sufficient funds through short-term debt instruments to finance its budget deficit. “On the other hand, rising yields and increasing domestic debt obligations could make it more expensive for the government to borrow in the future,” he said.
Meanwhile, in response to the recent auction results, the government has set an ambitious target of raising GHS 6.89 billion in the next T-bill auction. According to the analyst , this suggests a continued emphasis on leveraging short-term debt instruments as part of its broader borrowing strategy. “However, achieving this target will depend on several factors, including market liquidity, investor sentiment, and the government’s ability to manage its fiscal policies effectively,” he established.
The next few auctions will be closely watched by market participants as they look for signs of sustained demand or potential weakening in investor confidence. Mr Kwasi Mensah noted that if the trend of undersubscription were to continue, it could signal deeper concerns about the government’s fiscal position and its reliance on short-term borrowing to meet financing needs.
Analyst Perspective: A Blip, Not a Crisis
Mr Kwasi Mensah maintained that the recent undersubscription should be viewed as a temporary market reaction rather than a harbinger of a larger crisis. “The government’s borrowing strategy, while aggressive, has been met with consistent demand, and the slight yield increases are a natural response to the evolving market dynamics.”
The robust demand across all tenors indicates that investors still have faith in the government’s short-term debt instruments, despite the fiscal pressures it faces. This confidence is crucial as the government continues to navigate a challenging economic environment marked by inflation and limited access to external financing.
The path forward will require a careful balancing act as the government seeks to meet its financing needs while managing the risks associated with rising yields and increasing debt obligations. For now, market participants can take solace in the fact that demand remains strong, even if it falls short of ambitious targets.
A Closer Look at the Undersubscription
The November 15, 2024 auction marks the first shortfall after a five-week streak of oversubscriptions. The undersubscription of GHS 1.04 billion is noteworthy, given the government’s aggressive borrowing strategy in recent months.
Despite the shortfall, demand for T-bills remained robust, particularly for the 91-day bill, which saw bids amounting to GHS 3.94 billion. The 182-day and 364-day bills also attracted substantial interest, with investors bidding GHS 653 million and GHS 584 million, respectively.
All in all, while the undersubscription of the recent T-bill auction is a noteworthy event, it does not necessarily signal a broader issue. The market remains resilient, with continued investor interest suggesting that the government’s short-term debt strategy is still viable.
However, the government must remain vigilant and responsive to changing market conditions to sustain this confidence and ensure successful future auctions. The performance of upcoming auctions will be critical in determining whether this undersubscription was merely a blip or an early warning sign of growing concerns among investors.
READ ALSO: Sustainable Funding for SMEs: VCTF’s Push for Legislative Changes After 20 Years
