The government’s latest Treasury bills auction has exposed a fresh challenge in its domestic borrowing programme, with investors committing significantly less money than the amount targeted, even as interest rates continued to decline across the yield curve.
The government had set out to raise GH¢5.57 billion through the latest auction but managed to secure approximately GH¢3.44 billion in accepted bids, leaving a substantial GH¢2.13 billion gap between its borrowing target and the amount successfully mobilised.
The outcome represents a significant undersubscription, highlighting the growing difficulty of attracting sufficient investor funds at a time when Treasury bill yields are moving lower.
According to the Bank of Ghana’s auction results, the total bids tendered amounted to approximately GH¢4.33 billion, considerably below the government’s GH¢5.57 billion target.
Although the government accepted GH¢3.44 billion, the auction fell short of its intended borrowing amount, raising questions about investor appetite and the government’s ability to sustain its domestic financing strategy amid declining interest rates.
Government’s Borrowing Ambition Takes a Hit
The GH¢2.13 billion shortfall represents a notable setback for the government’s latest domestic borrowing exercise.
With an auction target of GH¢5.57 billion, the government was looking to attract substantial liquidity from the domestic financial market. However, the GH¢4.33 billion in bids tendered revealed that investors were not sufficiently enthusiastic to match the amount being sought.
The situation became even more pronounced when the government considered the bids it was willing to accept.
Out of the GH¢4.33 billion tendered, only GH¢3.44 billion was accepted, leaving the government with considerably less funding than originally planned.
This development comes at a particularly important time as Ghana continues to manage its public debt obligations, financing requirements and broader fiscal commitments.
Treasury bills remain an important instrument for government financing, providing a mechanism to mobilise short-term funds from banks, institutional investors, fund managers and other market participants.
However, the latest auction suggests that declining yields could be changing the dynamics of investor participation.
91-Day Bills Dominate Investor Participation
A breakdown of the auction results shows that the 91-day Treasury bill attracted the largest share of investor interest, accounting for approximately GH¢2.74 billion of the total bids tendered.
The government accepted GH¢2.51 billion from this category, making the shortest-tenor instrument the biggest contributor to the overall amount raised.
The strong participation in the 91-day instrument suggests that investors continue to demonstrate interest in short-term government securities, potentially reflecting their preference for shorter investment horizons amid changing market conditions.
However, even this segment failed to generate enough funds to compensate for the overall shortfall.
The 182-day bill recorded bids of GH¢721.62 million, out of which the government accepted GH¢596.62 million.
The performance of the six-month instrument was considerably smaller than that of the 91-day bill, indicating a more limited allocation of investor funds to the medium-term option.
Meanwhile, the 364-day Treasury bill attracted GH¢873.41 million in bids, but the government accepted only GH¢344.81 million.
The substantial difference between the bids tendered and accepted in the one-year category suggests that the government was considerably more selective in determining the amount it would take from investors at the prevailing rates.
Interest Rates Continue to Fall Despite Weak Subscription
Interestingly, the disappointing borrowing outcome came alongside another round of declines in Treasury bill yields.
Rather than offering higher returns to attract additional investor participation, the government continued to experience easing interest rates across all three maturities.
The yield on the 91-day Treasury bill declined by one basis point to 4.55%, extending the downward movement in short-term government borrowing costs.
The 182-day bill recorded a more significant decline of four basis points, falling from 6.20% in the preceding week to 6.16%.
Similarly, the yield on the 364-day instrument eased by two basis points to 9.46%.
The declining yields indicate that the cost of borrowing through Treasury bills continues to ease, potentially offering some relief to government finances.
However, the latest auction presents an interesting contradiction. While borrowing costs are declining, the government has struggled to attract enough funds to meet its financing target.
This raises an important question about the relationship between investor appetite and the returns being offered on government securities.
Are Lower Returns Changing Investor Behaviour?
The continued decline in Treasury bill yields could be influencing how investors allocate their funds across the domestic financial market.
Treasury bills have traditionally attracted investors seeking relatively predictable returns and short-term investment opportunities. However, as yields decline, investors may increasingly reassess whether the returns adequately compensate them for committing their funds.
Institutional investors, fund managers and other market participants may also consider alternative investment opportunities as the returns on government securities become less attractive.
Nevertheless, the latest auction results alone do not establish that investors are abandoning Treasury bills. The difference between bids tendered and accepted also reflects the government’s acceptance decisions, particularly in the 364-day category.
The GH¢4.33 billion tendered against the GH¢5.57 billion target, however, demonstrates that total investor submissions were already below the government’s expectations.
A Borrowing Challenge Amid Falling Yields
The latest auction presents a delicate balancing act for the government.
Lower Treasury bill rates are generally welcome because they can reduce the cost of domestic borrowing and potentially create room for cheaper financing across the economy.
However, sustaining lower rates while mobilising sufficient funds remains an important challenge.
If investor participation weakens further, the government could face pressure to reconsider its borrowing targets, adjust the returns offered or explore alternative financing arrangements.
The latest results therefore offer an important indication of the changing conditions in Ghana’s domestic debt market.
With GH¢3.44 billion secured against a GH¢5.57 billion target, the government has recorded a substantial financing gap at a time when Treasury bill yields are continuing to retreat.
The coming auctions will be particularly important in determining whether the shortfall represents a temporary development or an emerging pattern in the government’s domestic borrowing programme.
READ ALSO: IMF Reveals How Ghana Turned Economic Crisis Into Recovery









