An Investment Advisory and Fund Management firm, Tesah Capital, has stated that it expects the 2023 budget to have realistic targets because as the government negotiates with the IMF for a bailout and a possible debt restructuring with creditors, it is imperative that the managers of the economy have a better sense of the true state and outlook of the economy.
The Investment Advisor Firm noted that Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA) strongly rely on forecasts of key macroeconomic variables. It underscored that the worst possible outcome for the country is falling for the temptation of insufficient debt relief (either from the IMF or Creditors) leading to serial debt restructuring, all based on a false sense of optimism about economic targets.
“We may be a proud nation but desperate times such as this require realism. We are of the opinion that the 2022 budget presented by the minister of finance in November 2021 contributed to worsening economic outcomes in the country. All the targets presented in November 2021 had to be revised in the mid-year budget. We still expect some variables to end the year worse than their revised targets in the mid-year budget.”
Tesah Capital
Revision of targets
Commenting on the consistency with which government misses its macroeconomic targets, Tesah Capital noted that Real GDP growth rate was forecasted to be 5.8% in the 2022 budget but was later revised to 3.7%.
However, in the recent IMF global economic outlook, the fund’s economists project real GDP in Ghana to grow by 3.6%.
Inflation rate was also projected to end the year at the Bank of Ghana’s target of 8% but was revised in the mid-year budget to 28.5%. In the July 2022 monetary policy report by the Bank of Ghana, the economists at the Bank projected inflation to end the year at about 34%.
“Given the most recent weakening of the cedi and elevated inflation expectations, we expect inflation to end the year worse than the target of the government. The government also targeted a gross international reserve of not less than 4 months of import in the 2022 Budget but revised it to not less than 3 months.”
Tesah Capital
The Investment Advisory Firm noted that the gross international reserve declined by about $2 billion in the first half of the year alone. This was mainly due to the lack of international capital market access and sell-offs by investors who held government of Ghana bonds.
These conditions, according to Tesah Capital, have at best not improved in the second half of the year and thus, pose a severe risk to the gross international reserve outlook.
“We admit that missing an economic target or two is not the worst crime a minister of finance can commit. However, setting targets which give a false sense of optimism will be extremely detrimental to our IMF program and the possible debt restructuring, especially when there are clear and obvious indications of the true outlook of the economic indicators.”
Tesah Capital
Tesah Capital is of the view that if the government had been a little conservative in its outlook for revenue, inflation, or interest rates in the 2022 budget, it would have realized much earlier that public debt was becoming unsustainable.
This, it stated, would have led government to the IMF earlier than it did. “The 2023 budget statement should be void such bold and optimistic targets”, it warned.
Call for the budget to be more transparent
In addition to having realistic macroeconomic targets, Tesah Capital expects the budget to be more transparent especially in dealing with the looming public debt crisis. It stated that the DSA will require the government to declare all hidden and contingent liabilities.
According to Tesah Capital, this is central in assessing informed overall debt trajectory risks. It explained that being transparent with the economic (and in particular public debt) data helps to better apprehend distribution of risks among all stakeholders including the Ghanaian public, many of whom are government bond holders.
Tesah Capital further highlighted that recently, the ministry of finance has lagged in publishing key economic information especially when they are most needed. It urged the Finance Minister to fulfil his mandate under Public Financial Management Act, 2016 (Act 921) regarding the periodic update on the Medium-Term Debt Management Strategy.
“The last time the Medium-Term Debt Management Strategy was updated was March 2021. Given that the economic landscape in the country has changed and the Ghanaian public is longing for some forward guidance, we will suggest to the finance minister to fulfil this requirement.”
Tesah Capital
Tesah Capital believes that a transparent budget with realistic targets will go a long way to guide expectations, not only for creditors, but also the public. It also assured that it will continue to emphasize the need for the 2023 budget to be one that is prudent in spending and efficient in the use of public funds.
Ghana is currently experiencing one of the most challenging economic times in recent years. The difficulties confronting the country as it heads into the 2023 fiscal year include anemic economic growth, high unemployment, elevated inflation, severe currency depreciation, deteriorating gross international reserves and a looming public debt crisis.
These put the finance minister in a critical position to present a budget that meets Ghanaians’ expectations and gives hope of an economic “miracle” in the near term.
READ ALSO: The Government Has Failed To Diagnose The Main Cause Of Ghana’s Ailing Economy – Dr. Beyuo
