The World Bank has advised African governments not to adopt too-stringent rules of origin for initial stages of the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA), as such a move will restrict growth of the trade pact.

According to the World Bank report titled ‘Africa in the New Trade Environment’, current rules of origin under AfCFTA being debated need to be reformed so that they are simple, consistent across product groups and do not impose costs on either the firms or regional entities in administering such rules. This, according to the World Bank is because of the fact that various regional economic communities have different rules of origin – with some more complex than the others. The report indicated that it has the potential to interrupt trade flow; hence, efforts must be made to streamline them for AfCFTA.

“Given that each regional economic community has its own distinct rules of origin, some more complex than others, there is a need to streamline and simplify the rules so that they do not restrict trade flows and investment. Rules of origin that vary across products are likely to restrict the growth of regional value chains and regional industrial trade networks, because production of a single item often requires multiple intermediate inputs with varying rules of origin requirements.”
World Bank

Advice to Member States

The report further advised member-states to adopt rules of origin that are based on broad product classifications rather than rules based on product-specific criteria, as the latter tends to be costlier than the former; thereby making trade under the pact expensive.

“The AfCFTA is more likely to adopt product-specific rules than ones based on broad product classifications. Product-specific rules of origin are often considered more complex and require highly specified requirements for each product type, hence leading to stringent document requirements.

“Rules of origin that vary across products, especially at very low levels of classification, are likely to restrict the growth of regional value chains and regional industrial trade networks; because production of a single item often requires multiple intermediate inputs with varying rules of origin requirements. This may impose significant costs of compliance and verification.”
World Bank

Africa trade house — AfCFTA Headquarters in Ghana

For these and other reasons, the World Bank urges member-countries to start with simpler rules of origin, especially considering the varying manufacturing strengths of the continent in order not to disrupt the flow and vibrancy of trade desired under the AfCFTA.

The World Bank report averred that with the newly-minted AfCFTA, a more gradual approach that begins with more flexible, simpler and easier rules of origin based on broad product classifications and then moving slowly to relatively less flexible rules seems relevant. “Given the lack of a competitive manufacturing sector, stringent rules at the early stages would be too restrictive to build a vibrant regional value chain.”

“If Africa is to become the next manufacturing frontier, very flexible rules of origin in the early phases of integration should be used to enhance production capacity and build the institutional muscle needed to monitor and verify the rules of origin requirements which will eventually become less flexible with increased development.”
World Bank