Afghanistan’s ruling Taliban government has rejected accusations by the United States Department of State that it detains foreign nationals in order to gain leverage over other countries, insisting that individuals held in the country are arrested solely for violating Afghan laws.
The response from authorities in Kabul comes after the United States announced that Afghanistan had been designated a sponsor of wrongful detention.
The designation was made by US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who accused the Taliban of engaging in what Washington described as “hostage diplomacy.”
Afghanistan joined Iran as countries singled out by the US in the past two weeks for detaining Americans in hopes of extracting policy concessions.
In a statement addressing the US move, Afghanistan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs rejected the allegations and said that the country’s law enforcement actions were not intended to pressure other governments or extract concessions.
Afghan officials stressed that foreign nationals who are detained are held because they have violated local laws. According to the ministry, Afghan authorities “arrest people for violating laws not to make a deal.”
Officials in Kabul also described the US designation as “regrettable,” signaling their dissatisfaction with Washington’s characterization of the situation.
The US decision placed Afghanistan among a small group of countries accused by Washington of detaining foreign nationals in order to influence diplomatic negotiations.
In recent weeks, the United States has also singled out Iran in connection with similar accusations involving detained Americans.
American officials have warned that the detention of foreign nationals, including US citizens, undermines prospects for improved relations and complicates diplomatic engagement with governments accused of such practices. Washington has repeatedly called for the release of Americans it says are being held unjustly in Afghanistan.
Afghanistan’s foreign ministry, however, rejected the claim that detainees are being used as bargaining tools. Officials maintained that the country’s legal system is responsible for addressing violations of Afghan law and that arrests are not politically motivated.
The ministry also pointed to ongoing diplomatic engagement with the United States on matters related to detainees.
Afghan officials described these discussions as constructive, suggesting that communication between the two sides remains active despite the public disagreement over the designation.
In July, the Taliban delegation to a UN-led meeting in Doha said that Afghans detained at the US military base in Guantanamo Bay should be exchanged for Americans detained in Afghanistan.
The ministry on Tuesday described ongoing diplomatic discussions with the US on the matter as constructive. However, it underlined that any foreigners detained in Afghanistan had violated Afghan law. “The government of Afghanistan underscores that no foreign nationals have been detained for purposes of a deal,” the ministry iterated.
Detainees Released Upon Completion Of Legal Procedures
Moreover, the ministry asserted that certain individuals have been detained on charges of violating established laws, “and in many instances, they have been released in the normal course following the completion of legal procedures.”
The proposal highlighted the continuing complexity of detainee issues between the two sides. While the Taliban’s suggestion indicated a willingness to negotiate over prisoners, Afghan officials have continued to insist that foreign nationals held in the country were arrested because they violated local laws.
In its latest remarks, the Afghan foreign ministry reiterated that position, emphasizing that detentions are handled through domestic legal procedures rather than diplomatic bargaining. Officials said that individuals taken into custody are subject to Afghan legislation and judicial processes.
The disagreement between Kabul and Washington reflects wider tensions surrounding the international community’s engagement with Afghanistan’s current leadership.
Since the Taliban assumed control of the country following the withdrawal of US and allied forces, questions have persisted about governance, human rights, and diplomatic relations.
The designation announced by the United States adds another layer to those challenges, as it formally accuses Afghanistan of a practice Washington considers unacceptable.
Afghan authorities, however, have rejected that characterization and reiterated their claim that detentions are conducted strictly within the framework of national law.
For now, the issue of detained foreign nationals remains a sensitive point in the relationship between the United States and Afghanistan’s Taliban leadership.
While public statements from both sides highlight sharp differences in interpretation, Afghan officials say diplomatic discussions continue.
The outcome of those discussions may determine whether the dispute over detentions evolves into broader negotiations or remains a point of contention in already complex relations between the two governments.
READ ALSO: US Designates Afghanistan As State Sponsor Of Wrongful Detention
